That's some excellent advice on the sticky cards Icemud. I hadn't thought of cutting them down or placing them around that way. I used the idea of the dunks, although I purchased these
It's also sold as loose material in a large container. I knew I'd only need one or two of the small packets, so I went with them. I had a plan.
You can cut them open and sprinkle them onto the soil or soak them in your water overnight before every watering. Keep that up for a month and you've broken the life cycle. I finished up with a decent top-dress of neem seed meal, which I reapply at least between plantings. I haven't had a reaccurace of fungus gnats since. It's been months. Unfortunately, I do have a community of thrips enjoying my soil while I'm out of town that I didnt notice until right before I left, but there's nothing but cover crops in the pots right now, so I can get that under control easily after I get back home.
Ahhh..... the joys of organic gardening, eh?
Diatomaceous earth works much more effectively if it's puffed onto the surface than layered. If you think about this it makes perfect sense. It's really the crushed fossilized skeletal remains of tiny sea creatures. If you layer it, those tiny shards of bone have a better chance of linking together and forming a smooth surface that the insects can walk right across without damage. I've seen this happen on many grows, including one of my early rescue grows. Puffed on, those sharp edges stand a better chance of ripping into the exoskeletons of the fungus gnats, causing them to dehydrate and die.
Sand, IMHO smothers the soil surface. I've never been comfortable with that method. I use mulches, and sand doesn't allow for the decomposition of mulch material.