Lively discussion rather than rant imoThe Sip thing is ok. Been around forever. A company makes a thing called Earth Box that is the same. I’ve grown some great plants in 5 gal sip/modified hempy tyoe 5 gal buckets. The Swick on the other hand I’m not sure about. Seems like it causes issues.
If plants were as difficult to grow as we humans like to make it sometimes….. we wouldn’t be able to have this conversation. The seed germination “tek” is what blows my mind. Soak them and plant them. Only reason to do anything else is to get/test germ rates. Rant over
I have done two swick grows and had issues with calcium. I had specific objectives going in and it was meant to simplify my life not complicate it. I wanted to be able to leave my plants to self water for a few days if I needed to get away. That worked well for me in the seedling stage and in flower. A swick might work better if I top dress and top water to get the calcium percolating down through the soil. I have seen some success with this method. I haven't given up on the idea entirely.ETA not ever in my intention to discourage or discredit anyone, definitely not my MO