Life is too short to worry about something like that..It is just that I hope to reuse the soil, and do not want to overload it with calmag.
The plant is going to need calcium, might as well add enough to maintain its health.
How To Use Progressive Web App aka PWA On 420 Magazine Forum
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Life is too short to worry about something like that..It is just that I hope to reuse the soil, and do not want to overload it with calmag.
Thanks for sharing, gro.the best advice i ever got was : fill up the jars first, fuck around after.
Very true.a lot of times you have to do what you need to. not what you want to.
I think I have enough brownbud here to last me a couple of months until harvest. It makes nice Cannabis Dust, but I am really looking forard to greenbud for vaping and pressing.if you're growing sips, don't worry about organics, inorganics, any of that shit. short answer is it's not a big difference at this point, and you have greater priorities.
Thanks for the encouragement, gro. I appreciate it.what you wanna do is copy and paste what is working for others right now.
keep it simple.
once you get a little success, you'll move toward your own grow style as you complete more and more grows. every grower does.
you don't have to solve everything right now. just get some jars filled.
the rest works itself out with time.
True.Life is too short to worry about something like that..
The plant is going to need calcium, might as well add enough to maintain its health.
@bluter , you are awesome, man! I appreciate you trying to help me get my meds grown green!@el gringuito - just do a simple grow first. do regular nutes and a common media. use calmag. sips is a good style if you are set up for it now. otherwise get some fabric grow bags.
don't worry about organic / inorganic stuff. let's just get you growing decently first. the rest will happen as you develop.
if you could source megacrop i'd go with that for your nute needs to begin. it's super simple, and will teach you the crucial basics of what you need to know.
i could even take you through a hempy grow easily if you want. it's cheap and easy if you keep your nutes simple. but i'd recommend sips if you are already set for it.
organics can take a pile of real estate to do proper, and is best in huge grow beds or 25 gallon or larger grow bags. you may not have the infrastructure to pull it off.
don't keep doing what you are at the moment. you're tripping all over yourself. clean it up and simplify. we can help. just focus on the simple.
That is a good question. The author was careful to emphasize not to use too much. I think she said something like 1.2-1.4 ml per liter of water, so I summarized as 1.3, which is like 1/4 teaspoon.There is definitely some moisture held by the perlite since the roots are growing above the water line, but I don't know what part oxygen plays in the whole thing.
I add more water every morning to make sure it runs out the side hole. I also have the perlite cup in another cup to keep the water from spilling on the heat mat!
Apple cider is acidic, so I wonder if that makes any difference to the stems.
I can see that with the GLN Sweet Candy.I am 100% sure that the products you have posted the pics of are considered synthetic nutes, as they completely bypass the microbes in the soil and feed the plant directly.
Ohhh, you are talking about something completely other else. It sounds like you are talking about the Rev's book?Most people consider an LOS grow essentially to be fed by microbes in the soil "eating" the base elements and converting them into something the plant can use, and the plant then taking the elements from the microbes and sending them back into the soil to start the process again. That's a rough explanation but it gets to the difference between an organic and synthetic grow.
I get it.The ingredients in synthetic nutes are called salts (not to be confused with salt) and are mostly compounds of sulfates, nitrates, and phosphates. That's what's in MC and almost every other synthetic nutrient on the market.
Oh, ok, so you consider GF and DE to be organic. Is that because there is no presence of chemical 'nutes at all?Urine will act as a nitrogen source if you use it with another product, but it won't work well on its own. Also, GeoFlora is an actual organic top-dressed nute (there are others like Dr Earth as well).
Feeding the soil is what I am after.The other products you have posted pics of here or listed the ingredients for are not considered part of an organic grow if the organic taste is what you're after.
Personally I don't believe that anyone can tell the difference between well cured organic and synthetic-nute flowers, but that's a conversation for another day.
I was referring to the ingredient list to make Rev's soil or its equivalent. Expensive up front, free long term. And without the trial and error and many underperforming grows in the meantime.
Yeah, check out my supersoil recipe.
Yes, my plastic is dirty, and starts yellow.You just need to cover all the bases, and provide enough... NPK, calcium, magnesium, sulfur, and the micro-nutrients... zinc, iron, the other metals, and silicon. My plants are doing very well – I just need to work on bud size and yield now. I'm outside, so it's a different story, because I'm not able to pump the photosynthesis as much as an indoor grow. My solar exposure is limited, due to being surrounded by big trees, and the roofing of the greenhouses isn't ideal because it gets dirty.
It will be great to get to a place where we can have an outdoor garden again.My supersoil base is compost soil, coir, and perlite. Then I add the nutrients to that and mix it all up, in a good size wheelbarrow. I also add fresh worm castings.
I have rough measurements in mind when I add the nutes (powders), but I'm a bit like a mad scientist with it.
Ohhh... right. (I did not think of that.)I do add some kelp granules, not a lot... only for the iron and micro-nutrients. Keep in mind that kelp may contain a lot of sodium.
Concur.My view is that everything that goes into the soil, in terms of the organic matter (compost/coir) and minerals, becomes habitat and food for the microbes.
Hopefully. Because the first thing is the soil.And all of it works in synergy with the roots.
I consider those all to be "naturally occurring", and therefore I have no problems calling them "organic inputs".Most of what I'm using for nutes is mined minerals, guano (bat/seabird), and oyster shell.
Good to know.I don't consider most of it to be "synthetic" – i.e. derived from human-controlled chemical processes. (Potassium sulfate for organic agriculture is synthesized from natural sources. Gypsum is mined, but also processed.)
Yes, I will have to check your supersoil recipe again.I know you are sensitive to the spiritual side of growing, and I am also of that mind and heart. I decided I wouldn't use any animal products, as in bone meal, blood meal, etc. I've been keeping true to that; however, I did try some semi-soluble fish bone powder recently, because it's a great way to add phosphorous during flowering. I don't think I'll use it again though, because it's quite expensive for a small amount.
When you use enough of all these nutes, and proper pot size, the supersoil will carry your plants to late veg, early flower, or mid flower. At that point I will start fertigating with diluted urine, usually 8:1, and solution-grade potassium sulfate, stirred together. (Sometime both, sometimes one or the other.) In late flower, little to no urine. During early/mid flower I will also add some seabird guano (P) to the fertigation, although it's not solution grade.
It is organic as it does not use chemical salts as inputs.Does GF qualify as "organic" in your view?
Subcool's recipe is one of many methods of building living organic soil (LOS).It sounds like Subcool Supersoil does not qualify as "organic" in your view?
I haven't read Rev's book but as far as I know his growing methods are based on organic inputs.Ohhh, you are talking about something completely other else. It sounds like you are talking about the Rev's book?
So rather than organic (or mostly organic) inputs, the Rev is talking about an eco-sustainable system??
Yikes!! Is there like a short 5-10 minute video on that? Because I am running my tail off right now.
Most of the planet is eating food grown with synthetic nutrients. The plant takes up ions of NPK/Ca/Mg/S etc. and those ions look the same to the plant whether from an organic or synthetic source. The plant doesn't see a difference.I do not want to do to the planet anything that could cause anyone to have health like I have had.
Yes, both GF and Dr Earth (DE usually means diatomaceous earth around here!) use organic inputs.Oh, ok, so you consider GF and DE to be organic. Is that because there is no presence of chemical 'nutes at all?
Or what would you consider to be the distinguishing difference?
Then you are looking to avoid salts wherever possible.Feeding the soil is what I am after.
As I've mentioned, I'm not the one to tell you how to learn about building LOS, but Google searches for Living Organic Soil might help, along with searching this site for mentions of LOS.Yeah, that sounds good! I just need to learn more about it. Is there a short and easy way to learn more about it? (Do I Google, "The Rev Made Easy"?
Ahhh... now I think I am starting to understand your reasoning.It is organic as it does not use chemical salts as inputs.
Subcool's recipe is one of many methods of building living organic soil (LOS).
It will be great to get time to read it one day.I haven't read Rev's book but as far as I know his growing methods are based on organic inputs.
Most of the planet is eating food grown with synthetic nutrients. The plant takes up ions of NPK/Ca/Mg/S etc. and those ions look the same to the plant whether from an organic or synthetic source. The plant doesn't see a difference.
Thanks for the abbreviation lesson! I will update myself!Yes, both GF and Dr Earth (DE usually means diatomaceous earth around here!) use organic inputs.
Thanks for your patience while I refine my understanding.Then you are looking to avoid salts wherever possible.
As I've mentioned, I'm not the one to tell you how to learn about building LOS, but Google searches for Living Organic Soil might help, along with searching this site for mentions of LOS.
Yes, my Auto Blue Ace 2:1 are on GF, and that is the biggest and nicest they have looked at this stage! Everything is nice and green and clean. And the granules are very easy to work with. And the price was good (but the re-shipping will kill you!)I used Geoflora for my outdoor 'in ground' grows the last 3 years. I like it a lot!
I'd like to start by saying none of this has to do with me or what I think disqualifies a grow from being organic. I'm repeating what many if not most of the LOS growers on the site use as their criteria: bacteria and organic matter in the soil feed the plants rather than being bottle fed with nutrient salts.If any chemical salts are used, whether they are naturally occurring or not (e.g., dolomite lime), for you that disqualifies it as being organic, even though farmers in ancient times (as now) would have added known good amendments to their soil?
And does it make any difference as to how it is processed, in your view?
On that list, only epsom salts (magnesium sulfate) would be consider a salt-based nute. The others would be found in nature.Even though he recommends Epsom salts, dolomite lime, rock phosphate, and azomite??
Cool, gro. I understand that language. And it makes sense.I'd like to start by saying none of this has to do with me or what I think disqualifies a grow from being organic. I'm repeating what many if not most of the LOS growers on the site use as their criteria: bacteria and organic matter in the soil feed the plants rather than being bottle fed with nutrient salts.
Shed, I really appreciate you helping me to understand this. This is great information, and it was never really clear to me before. Now that you are asking such good questions, it is forcing me to refine my understanding, and I appreciate that very much.Potassium sulfate is not how LOS gardeners get their plants either potassium or sulfur. Potassium sulfate will split into ions of potassium and sulfur in the soil and be immediately available to the plant, no microbes involved. It works in completely inert media like coco or hydro for that reason. LOS growers tend to consider adding immediately available salts to the soil (i.e. synthetic nutrients) not to be part of an LOS grow. That doesn't mean that folks don't do it, as some LOS growers add bloom boosters or cal-mag made from salts. That's a call they make understanding the tradeoffs they feel are happening.
Yes, and I appreciate that a lot. I am learning a lot! I am just still confused why Subcool is cool, but Dude is a fool, when they both have the same kinds of salts.And as I have mentioned, I don't care what you do with your grow. I'm just trying to give you information to help you make decisions about how "organic" your grow will or wont be if you are adding salts to the grow.
Yes, I understand the question.How many and how often can you add them before you lose the organic flavor you seek or have some denigrating effect on the soil is not something I can offer any help with.
Ahh, ok!On that list, only epsom salts (magnesium sulfate) would be consider a salt-based nute. The others would be found in nature.
Maybe think of it as a percentage. Subcool is using epsom salts as a much smaller percentage than the bags you posted, which are closer to 100% synthetic nutes. They may add some humic acid or kelp and such in there, but the N, P, and K are not organically sourced.I guess I "went organic with Subcool", and do not understand why his salts are ok, and Dude's salts are not.
Yes, ok. I would like to do the best I can, but maybe not practical at this moment...Maybe think of it as a percentage.
Wait. What????Subcool is using epsom salts as a much smaller percentage than the bags you posted, which are closer to 100% synthetic nutes.
Right.They may add some humic acid or kelp and such in there, but the N, P, and K are not organically sourced.
Well, thank you again. Bummer that GF does not send me a cargo ship! Lol. Right? Like I am top on their radar...There are tons of LOS recipes out there, and CBDhemp posted a link to his as well. I'm not making any value judgements about any of them; which ones are okay or not okay. I'm giving you information to make informed decisions.
I put the 1 inch layer of earthworm castings up top of my SIP build, do I still use the @StoneOtter SIP Fix, and add the 4 mL of Calmag per gallon of water?
(And do I put that water over EWC and the soil? Or down into the res?)
run a little in the res. use the liquid version. start at 1/4 to 1/2 dose and watch how the plant responds.
Yeah, but not pure salts, gro. It smells and handles like fine fish flourI already pointed them out as you were posting and I won't have time to find them again tonight, but definitely the pic of the bag you posted a few days ago. If they mention P2 or P2O5 or K2 or K2O they would be salts.
Ok, @bluter says to monitor.Hmmm....
Dude's website says:
CALMAG APPLICATION RATE
Seedlings and Small Plants
Use 1 teaspoon (5 ml) per gallon.
Mature Vegetative Plants
Use 1 – 3 teaspoons (5 – 15 ml) per gallon.
Mature Flowering Plants
Use 2 – 3 teaspoons (10 – 15 ml) per gallon.
I would say they are just entering into flowering, so maybe, 2 tsp. normally?
So then, since this soil is going to get tightened/trashed no matter what, and I have a refractometer on the way, maybe go with 2 teaspoons, meaning 10ml per gallon? (And maybe go a little light because they are just now entering into flower, but then maybe go a little heavy, because they have not had any up until now... so... 2 teaspoons?)
And down the feed tube?
And then watch what happens?? Lol.