NO question the are way more effecient. And my tone was not inteded, it came off douchey and I apoligize. Ive looked at 5 other sites and been researching since my outburst and the only way it makes sense is distance. Given the same size box with lighting being the same distance its no contest. Also I have learned that the spiral of the lower watt CFLs dissapate the heat very rapidly as aposed to one bulb.
But, Ill admit I didnt consider all options and that Invi's point under proper circumstances is right. With a proper grow area, and cooltube options, a HPS can run cooler than cfl's. Especially considering for any effeciency the CFL's must be so so close to the plants.
I was thinking in terms of a small grow box, basically exchanging one for another. I didnt consider a tent like setup or proper exhaust and cooling techniques.
No matter what the HPS is WAY WAY better if heat can be controlled. ME = Dumb. Invi = Smart.