I'm glad that I'm not an official product reviewer. I'd feel pressured to write a good review, or fudge the results in the sponsor's favor.
There might be some of that here, because there
might be some of that anywhere. On the other hand, the 150,000+ other members registered here are free to comment on a person's review thread, posting their own thoughts and/or experiences. I would expect to see far less of that potential issue (and I believe I do) here than on a YouTube channel that seems to exist solely to post (glowing?) video reviews of products and which ends up looking like a video version of Maximum Yield
. Or even on products' Amazon reviews; I have seen a fair few instances of "seller stated item would be free (half off, etc.) upon the posting of a review."
I have bought some products from a manufacturer that I felt should be improved. In these cases, I contact the manufacturer letting them know what I think. Sometimes this even results in product improvements.
That happens here, too. I got a pair of recent-design SP-150 LED products. I thought they were nice, but commented that I wished they had some kind of simple reflector around the perimeter, nothing fancy, just something to redirect some portion of the light output that would otherwise be hitting the grow space's walls instead of the plants. A simple thing, really. Then, when I later won the company's
next new product - the TS-1000 - I was pleased to see that it had a... simple reflector around the perimeter! I don't know whether my comment led to that; I am just one person, with one voice. Perhaps someone else caught their...
ear, maybe several of us all mentioned the same thing and made an impact, I don't know. Regardless, I wanted to see a feature added, the next product included that feature... and I appreciate it. Not just because of the thing itself, but because I cannot help (rightly or wrongly) feeling that
someone "listened". If I had ever gotten that feeling back in my Microsoft-using days, maybe I would... Nah, who am I kidding, lol, linux for the win (lol). But my appreciation of
Mars-Hydro grew beyond that of "just" a sponsor that helps support my favorite spot on the Internet.
Come to think of it, I remember that company's first-generation grow tents. A lot of people liked them, some probably did not. Then, their forum representative posted that the people who decide such things at the company were thinking of redesigning them, and asked
US for our ideas about how they could improve their product. Many of us posted in response over a relatively short period of time, the rep probably felt like she was herding cats (in the virtual sense)... and the next generation of their grow tents included some of the things that were suggested.
Which is, IMHO, how it's
supposed to work. Yeah, I would have to state that I am 100% in favor of posting reviews, either formally in their own threads or informally in the
sponsors' "general" threads. Because, here at least, they're not so much simple reviews... They are "seeds" capable of "growing"
useful discussions.
Ramble ramble ramble
.