The Everything SWICK Club: 2023 And Beyond

Hi PerkPot
PerkPot said:
I just had a pot stop swicking so I changed the string. It was def dirty w a little root growth. I top water once a week to add nutrients(like elm dirt) Just a couple cups. Not a lot.

IMG_7038.jpeg


IMG_7039.jpeg
Click to expand...
Very interesting, thanks. How do you get the pot swicking again if it stops? I would have thought that the reservoir running dry would stop the swick too?
 
Carmen Ray said:
.....
Do you ever see calcium deficiency at any stage of their growth?
Do their roots chase the water source neglecting the top feeder function? / Do you ever top water?

Your plant looks great!
Click to expand...

@Carmen Ray I rarely see any major calcium deficiencies just a few spots here and there.
Every two or three reservoir fill ups I add some Blue Planet Cal/Mag till mid flowering then I stop adding it.

The roots rarely go down the wick looking for water. Sometimes they are packed solid on the top of the soil and sometimes not, haven't figured out the reason for that yet. I don't see a lot on top right now but I'm only mid first week flowering.
I only top watered the first two times after transplant then only after a top dress or tea.

The current grow I mixed a full dose of veg and a half dose flower of @GeoFlora Nutrients throughout the soil before transplant. Next weekend will be end of week two flowering and I'll top dress some GF flowering.
 
Hash Hound said:
@Carmen Ray I rarely see any major calcium deficiencies just a few spots here and there.
Every two or three reservoir fill ups I add some Blue Planet Cal/Mag till mid flowering then I stop adding it.
Click to expand...
As a preventive measure. Ok, ty.
Hash Hound said:
The roots rarely go down the wick looking for water. Sometimes they are packed solid on the top of the soil and sometimes not, haven't figured out the reason for that yet. I don't see a lot on top right now but I'm only mid first week flowering.
Click to expand...
Ah, I have a question and you may one of the best suited to answer. I have this one plant that feels packed solid with roots, to more than a third of the way up the fabric pot. I have been thinking it could be root bound. It is very pale indeed. It's 28 days into flower. I have thought it might be good to up pot to make more nutrients available to those roots, but I also don't want to cause irreversible harm to the flowering plant. Are you able to offer any advice to help me decide? Shed has shown me a brilliant way to do it that would hopefully cause very little stress, but maybe this rooting is normal, Idk?
Hash Hound said:
I only top watered the first two times after transplant then only after a top dress or tea.
Click to expand...
How many top dress / tea applications are there in a typical grow?
Hash Hound said:
The current grow I mixed a full dose of veg and a half dose flower of @GeoFlora Nutrients throughout the soil before transplant. Next weekend will be end of week two flowering and I'll top dress some GF flowering.
Click to expand...
Is it for use with LOS? Some of those ingredients are already in the soil I use.
 
PerkPot said:
Hi Carmen. My 5 gallon pots are packed with roots top to bottom. I use a chop stick to poke some holes through before I top feed otherwise it just comes out the sides.
Click to expand...
Hi PerkPot, do you think I should rather leave the plant in its existing pot? My concern is how pale my plant is. I think it must be hungry and it is crucial bud building time now.
Gelato auto 1

Gelato auto 1

Day 63
 
Carmen Ray said:
Hi PerkPot, do you think I should rather leave the plant in its existing pot? My concern is how pale my plant is. I think it must be hungry and it is crucial bud building time now.
Click to expand...
Thought I'd mention this unrelated to the plumbing work you're going to have:

"Our urine contains significant levels of nitrogen, as well as phosphorous and potassium. The relative ratios are typically around 11 parts nitrogen to 1 part phosphorus to 2.5 parts potassium." That's 11-1-2.5 for short.
Source
 
InTheShed said:
Thought I'd mention this unrelated to the plumbing work you're going to have:

"Our urine contains significant levels of nitrogen, as well as phosphorous and potassium. The relative ratios are typically around 11 parts nitrogen to 1 part phosphorus to 2.5 parts potassium." That's 11-1-2.5 for short.
Source
Click to expand...
Are you suggesting I harvest my urine and feed it to the plants? :hmmmm:
 
Carmen Ray said:
Are you suggesting I harvest my urine and feed it to the plants?
Click to expand...
If you think it's a nutrient issue rather than a root/watering issue then yes I am, though "harvest" would not have been my choice of words. :)
 
InTheShed said:
If you think it's a nutrient issue rather than a root/watering issue then yes I am, though "harvest" would not have been my choice of words. :)
Click to expand...
What alternatives do I have? I take medication and I have read that it is unsafe to use urine as a fertilizer when on medication and or hormones. I think it is a nutrient issue. The plant has been praying beautifully, which would indicate that watering is spot on and roots have adapted.
 
Carmen Ray said:
As a preventive measure. Ok, ty.

Ah, I have a question and you may one of the best suited to answer. I have this one plant that feels packed solid with roots, to more than a third of the way up the fabric pot. I have been thinking it could be root bound. It is very pale indeed. It's 28 days into flower. I have thought it might be good to up pot to make more nutrients available to those roots, but I also don't want to cause irreversible harm to the flowering plant. Are you able to offer any advice to help me decide? Shed has shown me a brilliant way to do it that would hopefully cause very little stress, but maybe this rooting is normal, Idk?
Click to expand...
I have no clue on this one, I'd consider Sheds method

Carmen Ray said:
How many top dress / tea applications are there in a typical grow?
Click to expand...
I'm rarely top dress but since I'm using the Geoflora I'll do the 2-4-6 week top dress which I will experiment by using the well method, poke two or three finger sized holes and putting the GF in there.
Normally I would use two or three teas during a grow and that's it.

Carmen Ray said:
Is it for use with LOS? Some of those ingredients are already in the soil I use.
Click to expand...
I using Coast of Maine Growers Blend in one 7g bag, in another I'm using CoM on the bottom and PMO on the top of a 7g bag, and I have a 4g plastic pot with straight PMO. All three were amended with the GF
The CoM says it will sustain a plant for 42 days in a 7g bag but I'm still going to do the GFs recommended 2-4-6th weeks
 
Carmen Ray said:
What alternatives do I have? I take medication and I have read that it is unsafe to use urine as a fertilizer when on medication and or hormones. I think it is a nutrient issue. The plant has been praying beautifully, which would indicate that watering is spot on and roots have adapted.
Click to expand...
Answered in your thread here!
 
Okay, this I found fascinating! I thought I was going to find a bunch of thick water roots in that grow bag. Instead I found a solid mass of feeder roots. They were so tightly bound I couldn't break it apart. The roots were uniformly dense throughout the bag.

Gelato auto 1

Gelato auto 1

rootopsy

Gelato auto 1

Gelato auto 1

rootopsy

Gelato auto 1

Gelato auto 1

rootopsy
 
Carmen Ray said:
Okay, this I found fascinating! I thought I was going to find a bunch of thick water roots in that grow bag. Instead I found a solid mass of feeder roots. They were so tightly bound I couldn't break it apart. The roots were uniformly dense throughout the bag.
Click to expand...
What is that telling you?
 
InTheShed said:
What is that telling you?
Click to expand...
It's telling me to put the plant in a 7 Gal, bomb it on the swick, top dress and feed extra calmag I think. I think the plant got hungry. I think the initial shock was from a super soil that wasn't fit for purpose and after the dramatic first flush it didn't properly recover. This coming grow will be a trad top water grow, but I am reconsidering the swick option for a future grow. What are you impressions, Shed?
 
Carmen Ray said:
It's telling me to put the plant in a 7 Gal, bomb it on the swick, top dress and feed extra calmag I think. I think the plant got hungry. I think the initial shock was from a super soil that wasn't fit for purpose and after the dramatic first flush it didn't properly recover. This coming grow will be a trad top water grow, but I am reconsidering the swick option for a future grow. What are you impressions, Shed?
Click to expand...
My impressions are your impressions! If you can pack a 5(?) gallon then a 7 gallon is definitely in order if you SWICK again. Maybe 7 gallons no matter how you're growing. :)
 
I think I've posted this before but I'm not sure. It was sold as a poinsettia planter.
I have to cut this mint plant back every two or three months.
I've tried using 2L bottle but it is to weak and collapses in from the vacuum and all the water comes out.
I have experimented with juice bottles which seem to be stronger,
For swickers using perlite or stones, a bottle with a small hole at the desired level placed in the reservoir will allow water out when it falls below the hole and also act as a water gague once the level in the bottle falls. Kepping the vacuum is the key to not letting all the water come out at once.

sip tray 1.JPG

sip tray 1.JPG


sip tray 2.JPG

sip tray 2.JPG

 
whoops. Post created by accident before i had my thoughts together.

Trying to understand the swick thing and how it is different from a hempy type bucket. I’ve run what I call a modified hempy with perlite higher than the outlet holes creating a space between the soil and water table. A home made earth box essentially. The appeal in this imo is the ability to get nutrients directly to the roots and leeching down through the soil.

Not being critical in the least. Always interested to see new ideas and perspectives on why people theme the approach they do.
 
Slapalottapuss said:
Trying to understand the swick thing and how it is different from a hempy type bucket. I’ve run what I call a modified hempy with perlite higher than the outlet holes creating a space between the soil and water table.
Click to expand...
Hey Slaps, that was my last grow exactly! I think there was too much perlite above the overflow hole in mine (because the water never wicked into the soil), so mine really seemed more like a hempy grow with a bucket of dry soil above it. That was a good thing or it would have tipped over if the only thing holding it down was perlite!

Can't complain since it turned out well, but I was hoping for the moist soil others get in SWICKs.

Build here. Plant here. Harvest here. Rootpsy here.
 
Back
Top Bottom