Things won't get nasty in my little corner of 420mag. In general I avoid organic soil threads because they inspire Jihad like fervor. Big plants often do very well in the no-till LOS. Check out Soil Girl.
am I the good example here or the jihadist? A little of both I suppose. Oh gosh PeeJay, missed you, even if you didn't miss my thread's fervor. Catching up, will be caught up soon but I wanna stop on the way.
I'm glad I saw your thoughts PeeJay. I also think the CC mix is heavy and have been using his recipe as more of a guideline. Most recently I've been doing his cubic foot recipe for 10 gallons instead of 7.5, and its been working better than before at the start. I've also been using your seedling mix, then transplanting into the LOS. (Not all of us are scared of transplanting haha
- I don't use a SWICK either. However, I do use your flushing method every now and then, whether just to flush or water.) I've done all kinds of soil experiments... a hybrid of your soil and CC's amendments, some Kellogg's soil experiments (like Lester uses), some lighter or heavier than CC's recipes (really, hardly a pot or two of my soil is alike at this point
), I'm even just starting an experiment in organic MG mixed with some of CC's amendments and cow manure. I'm very open minded to soil lol, whatever works out for you.
I really enjoy LOS because I find it a rewarding and uplifting way to grow. Like Sue said there are some out there that put on a clinic in top notch cannabis growing in this soil, that seems to improve with every plant grown in it. I'm also trying to move away from harmful to the planet and person non-renewable ingredients like SPM and perlite and vermiculite -which I remember you warning me about once lol- as a personal choice, and I see lots of personality in all of my plants despite the one size fits all approach - your approach is pretty one size fits all too at face value you know, having the same mixes for seed, veg and flower. It's up to you as a grower to bring versatility to the mix as your plants require, and you help others do that very willingly. Since switching from using only your methods to supplementing them with LOS amendments and moving on to doing CC-like No-tills, my plants have done very well. Also, I ran my no-tills on the cheap until pretty recently. There's some versatility at work here.
Lately I've been spending a lot of money very un prudently though lol. by no means do I tell people they have to spend like me to get similar results though. I've been spoiling myself. Recently I got the BAS IPM kit, including your Dr Oz water LOL - I was Oz'ed, definitely didn't really need coconut water, nor the aloe powder that came with it, I already have a freakin' aloe plant lol. I feed my worms BAS craft blend and yum yum mix and rock dusts, geesh. Not necessary, but makes a good vermicompost. -People can maintain an LOS for minimal cost and effort actually, I've seen it, I've just not represented that very well. :\ what can I do, I like throwing money at things I guess lol, its money right it will make things grow.
maybe a next experiment of mine will use strictly dollar bill fed worm castings.
after such success with your soils, I wasn't very quick to discard my guanos and 'PJ soil' amendments or buy into the CC LOS notion that all poo is bad, unless thoroughly composted and re-pooed by worms.
I will be mixing more of your soil recipes in the future, and also doing my own experiments with them. CC's mix and LOS style growing can be improved upon no doubt, but so can yours imo, at least for me and my situation, I'm glad to have experimented with different amendments and mixes and techniques. I think LOS and PJ soil can find a balance somewhere in the middle of prudence and long term improvement and be a splendid mix. Your soil is undeniably a great organic mix, your plants are gorgeous.
Anyways... my new tent just got here... wow that must be a record. Lol so excited, will catch up later.