I surely don’t disagree that exercise is a good. ANd that strengthening the appropriate parts of your body to carry around your skeleton is a good thing. And I’m not arguing, I don’t think. Just talking about it. I do think there’s inevitably a bit of assumption going in whenever anyone thinks they know how someone else ought to fix up what ails them. Thing is - we cant know. And we can’t responsibly recommend certain exercises for a back issue unless we have some expertise AND are present wiht that person. It’s otentially dangerous is all. There are heaps of other ways someone in Doogs’ position might help to heal and strengthen a probe back, like yoga or Pilates but it still requires skilled guidance, especially when working with injuries, and particularly long term ones.
Seeing as I’m here - and you’ve caught me in the middle of a little cannabis detox so I’m fairly manic
(lucky you guys!
) - there is a different school of thought that says that weight lifting has it all wrong because it seeks to power up the large muscle groups and make them hold up the skeleton. Instead, try thinking of it this way for a minute... fitness practices like Pilates and yoga work on all the small ligaments and tendons and work on getting them strong and flexible with the body in the appropriate alignment so that
the skeleton effectively supports itself - thus freeing up the large muscles to a great extent, for extra curricular tasks like powerful movement and lifting heavy weights without damage.
Yeah - there are really a lot of different ways to think about strength and fitness and injury...
... oh chit... forgot I’m not smoking this week - here someone take this!