Cherries DubeLee In A S.I.P. - An LOS Grow

This is for the clonex that's made for the rez. Seperate from the gel.
Ahh thanks! Like Mel said it must be to give them a bit of a jump start when the roots do appear. ↓
I think this stuff is there so they'll have something other than the leaves to use to start growing as their new roots get started.
In that case it would probably need hydro conditions for them to take it up.

I would guess clonex is chelated and can't unchelate at the wrong ph. Just a guess tho...
I wonder if anyone really gets iron, zinc, copper, and manganese deficiencies in just-rooted clones, though they're probably just covering their bases. Total amounts of chelated nutes are under 1% of the solution, and that's true in most synthetics like FF, GH, MC, etc.
I'm having thoughts of the summer grow!
Me too, about yours!
 
Yes, if you're going to use that solution for your hydro grow, you would need the correct pH to access all of the nutrients (not just the tiny amount of chelated ones). Of course anyone growing in hydro is going to pH their water!
"soak medium for several hours or add to Aeroponic system."

Im not a hydro guy at all so forgive me, just trying to learn. I use a KloneKing Aerocloner and if this makes better clones I'm in. If thats reference to a hydro system I guess I'm out lol. Are medium and aeroponic system hydro things? or cloning things?
 
Im not a hydro guy at all so forgive me, just trying to learn. I use a KloneKing Aerocloner and if this makes better clones I'm in. If thats reference to a hydro system I guess I'm out lol. Are medium and aeroponic system hydro things? or cloning things?
I used to use the same aeroponic cloner that Otter is using (build here) and never pH'd the water. As has been mentioned, pH only relates to the uptake of nutes by the roots, so until there are roots the pH doesn't matter (within reason of course ;) ). Once there are roots you can move your plants into their final medium, and if that's hydro you would be pH'ing your water at that point as hydro requires.

If you leave them in the cloner for any length of time after roots you may begin to see deficiencies (not just of the specific chelated micronutes), and while that may be from the fact that the pH is incorrect for hydro feeding, it could be from the fact that the strength of Clonex liquid mix might not be strong enough for plants that age.
 
"Use Clonex Clone Solution, a continuous liquid feed plant nutrient, with each irrigation."

From the clonex site. Its plant food to be used in addition to clonex rooting gel. PH is needed to unchelate it
I use Clonex too.

I don’t mean to talk myself up while talking myself up lol, but my clone game is solid. Particularly monstercropped clones. I really enjoy the process.

I have never pH’ed in my life.
 
Interesting conversation about cloning. I dip my cuttings in cloning gel and pop them into perlite. When I see strong roots they get transplanted into a seedling pot (same size as solo cup) and watered carefully sso that their rootss have time to develoop and strengthem (this time I put mine on a swick and that did the watering for me.) I am growing in craft LOS in 20 L cloth bags.

@Azimuth et al, does sub-irrigation work in a similar way delivering ph'd nutes to the roots? And, it's not necessary to PH if you are growing in LOS, ammirite? I certainly don't but I am also aware that our tap water is fine and I leave it to dechlorinate before filling the reseroir.

If my plants look a little untidy it is my ham fistedness.

Beeautifull Sunday friends :green_heart:
 
! Like Mel said it must be to give them a bit of a jump start when the roots do appear.
I think he hit it on the head.
"soak medium for several hours or add to Aeroponic system."

Im not a hydro guy at all so forgive me, just trying to learn. I use a KloneKing Aerocloner and if this makes better clones I'm in. If thats reference to a hydro system I guess I'm out lol. Are medium and aeroponic system hydro things? or cloning things?
Here's the roots my last time.
I use Clonex too.

I don’t mean to talk myself up while talking myself up lol, but my clone game is solid. Particularly monstercropped clones. I really enjoy the process.

I have never pH’ed in my life.
Your clone game is on Tra!
Interesting conversation about cloning. I dip my cuttings in cloning gel and pop them into perlite. When I see strong roots they get transplanted into a seedling pot (same size as solo cup) and watered carefully sso that their rootss have time to develoop and strengthem (this time I put mine on a swick and that did the watering for me.) I am growing in craft LOS in 20 L cloth bags.

@Azimuth et al, does sub-irrigation work in a similar way delivering ph'd nutes to the roots? And, it's not necessary to PH if you are growing in LOS, ammirite? I certainly don't but I am also aware that our tap water is fine and I leave it to dechlorinate before filling the reseroir.

If my plants look a little untidy it is my ham fistedness.

Beeautifull Sunday friends :green_heart:
One of the best things about growing is that there's so many ways to do things! 🐷👐:laughtwo:
 
If you leave them in the cloner for any length of time after roots you may begin to see deficiencies (not just of the specific chelated micronutes), and while that may be from the fact that the pH is incorrect for hydro feeding, it could be from the fact that the strength of Clonex liquid mix might not be strong enough for plants that age.
And, checking a bottle if the Clonex gel, it does not mention pH like it does on the cloning liquid so it does seem like that step on the liquid versiom is for  after the roots form.

@Azimuth et al, does sub-irrigation work in a similar way delivering ph'd nutes to the roots?
Yes, it seems to, at least in a SIP since we have roots down at the water level. I'd imagine it would work the same with a Swick unless the elements of the nutes were somehow too heavy for the wicking action to lift them, but I would be surprised if that were true. @Hash Hound could likely confirm that.

And, it's not necessary to PH if you are growing in LOS, ammirite?
Within reason, True. In an organic grow, the microbes and roots handle moving the pH around as needed.

Synthetic nute manufacturers chelate their nutes often with salts so each becomes available at a different pH so that they effectively don't mix in the bottle, so correctly pHing your water is important so that you start out at the right level and then the drift upwards takes the pH to increasingly higher levels releasing the various nutrients from their chelated bonds along the way.

At least that's how I understand it to work.
 
Synthetic nute manufacturers chelate their nutes often with salts so each becomes available at a different pH
Here is some info on what chelates are and what they're for:

Which elements are chelated?
Iron (Fe), zinc (Zn), manganese (Mn), copper (Cu), boron (B), chlorine (Cl), molybdenum (Mo), and nickel (Ni).


Why?
You may recognize some of these as being hard metallic substances, which they are. In order for plants to use them, the metal needs to be converted into a water soluble form called ions.

These ions float around in the water that surrounds soil particles. If they react with oxygen they are converted into a form that plants can’t use. They can also interact with other ions which may cause them to precipitate as solids, making them unavailable to plants.

Chelates are organic molecules (in the chemical sense) that pick up and hold the metal ions so that they don’t react with oxygen or other ions. Even though chelates hold on to the metal ions, plants can still absorb them through the roots and use them as nutrients.

Chelates make it easier for plants to find certain nutrients.

What are nutrient salts?
A salt is any molecule that is made up of two or more ions. Ammonium nitrate (NH4NO3) is a salt and is made up of an ammonium ion (NH4) and a nitrate ion (NO3). Potassium chloride (KCl) is common in fertilizer and is made up of a potassium ion (K) and a chlorine ion (Cl). There are hundreds of different salts.


correctly pHing your water is important so that you start out at the right level and then the drift upwards takes the pH to increasingly higher levels releasing the various nutrients from their chelated bonds along the way.
There is no such thing as water pH drift in soil. Water quickly becomes the pH of the soil (yes, even in small closed containers!), not vice versa. However, soil pH can change over many months because of nitrogen type or water with high alkaline content.
 
Here is some info on what chelates are and what they're for:

Which elements are chelated?
Iron (Fe), zinc (Zn), manganese (Mn), copper (Cu), boron (B), chlorine (Cl), molybdenum (Mo), and nickel (Ni).


Why?
You may recognize some of these as being hard metallic substances, which they are. In order for plants to use them, the metal needs to be converted into a water soluble form called ions.

These ions float around in the water that surrounds soil particles. If they react with oxygen they are converted into a form that plants can’t use. They can also interact with other ions which may cause them to precipitate as solids, making them unavailable to plants.

Chelates are organic molecules (in the chemical sense) that pick up and hold the metal ions so that they don’t react with oxygen or other ions. Even though chelates hold on to the metal ions, plants can still absorb them through the roots and use them as nutrients.

Chelates make it easier for plants to find certain nutrients.

What are nutrient salts?
A salt is any molecule that is made up of two or more ions. Ammonium nitrate (NH4NO3) is a salt and is made up of an ammonium ion (NH4) and a nitrate ion (NO3). Potassium chloride (KCl) is common in fertilizer and is made up of a potassium ion (K) and a chlorine ion (Cl). There are hundreds of different salts.



There is no such thing as water pH drift in soil. Water quickly becomes the pH of the soil (yes, even in small closed containers!), not vice versa. However, soil pH can change over many months because of nitrogen type or water with high alkaline content.
As I have stated earlier, Im not a hydro or coco guy and I'm not trying to start an argument, just learning, so without understanding or trying to pick a fight I ask the following question...
"Why do hydro and coco guys say you need to flush the salts if in fact there are no salts to flush?" Do they really mean flush something else but incorrectly call it salt?
 
"Why do hydro and coco guys say you need to flush the salts if in fact there are no salts to flush?" Do they really mean flush something else but incorrectly call it salt?
It's not incorrect to call them salts at all, though calling them "salt" makes it confusing. Most of the ingredients that make up synthetic nutes are salts.

The reason some synthetic nute folks like to flush their media clean is because a solid medium can accumulate unused salts over time, and clearing them out can be good.
 
It's not incorrect to call them salts at all, though calling them "salt" makes it confusing. Most of the ingredients that make up synthetic nutes are salts.

The reason some synthetic nute folks like to flush their media clean is because a solid medium can accumulate unused salts over time, and clearing them out can be good.
But when they are wet they are no longer salts as per your links, so its confusing. If they arent salts why would you be flushing salts? Are they letting the medium dry?
 
But when they are wet they are no longer salts as per your links, so its confusing. If they arent salts why would you be flushing salts? Are they letting the medium dry?
If you prefer you can call them ions, but they tend to be referred to as salts, maybe because it looks like there's a salt accumulation on the outside of cloth grow bags!

Plants don't use everything we feed them, and what they don't can accumulate in the solid medium.
 
Back
Top Bottom