Not with those who appreciated the impressive reduction in crime as a result of the policy.
Giuliani also is in favor of gun control, assault weapons (I despise this term, assault is an action, not a weapon type) bans, national registries, and a whole bunch of other 2A infringements. He is the reason Bloomberg was even able to sue gun manufacturers to begin with, his (Giuliani) lawsuit against Beretta being one of the keys to this. His disregard for the rights of citizens doesn’t stop at the 4th amendment. His “policies” were so effective because of his open embrace of strict gun control.
All of these politicians are two faced snakes that rarely are successful for the reasons they claim. They have no problem stepping all over Americans rights when it benefits them, regardless of party.