Okay, here goes.
:circle of love
*Crosses fingers*
Do not mess with a dragon...
for you are crunchy and taste good with ketchup.
I'm completely blind and I WILL bring up some girls, no matter how long it takes!
No, didn't work this time, but very close. I wonder if "hyphen" would be the correct word instead of "dash". Never occurred to me to call them that, but I'll bet your reader would recognize that instead?
So, it should be this:
colon (symbol)
circle (word)
hyphen (symbol)
of (word)
hyphen (symbol)
love (word)
colon (symbol)
I will bet it will work that way! your reader read the dash as a space and put a blank space where the hyphens would have gone.
My bad! Also, the last colon did not show up in your attempt. Remember it has to begin and end with the colon symbol.
You can't see me, but I'm smiling with you!
Edit: If you haven't read this before this edit, read the post from grizzwald first. That might be the simple method.