Haha that and my usual bumbling screw-ups Inda! But on the bright side I've got lots of room for improvement
Doc as usual you make a lot of sense, and I agree there's a happy medium in there somewhere.
For me this clone sog has a lot of appeal.
I don't have massive lighting available and I think for the hobby/cfl grower in particular this is a great way to manage light penetration. I believe that once I get my ducks lined up properly I'll be matching or exceeding the yield from my first grow with only 1/2 - 2/3 the watts I used then.
I'm not really worried about 'bag appeal' although of course we all want beautiful nugs. I jarred all my main colas separately last grow and I didn't notice any difference between them and the side buds as far as the taste or high went, so if the main colas are a little smaller and the side colas a bit bigger that's fine for me.
And I gotta say that while undersized due to flowering too soon, the bubbliecious clones have some awesome looking nugs.
Finally I've had more mold issues than I like to think about, and I believe that smaller colas and defoliating both help to reduce the mold risk.
Like you said there's no one sized fits all approach, we each have to try and customize what we have to maximize what we're going after.