Okay, I think I have a better idea of what happened (I thought you had recently logged in for the first time in a while).I log in every day.
The 2 alerts that stayed would be for "Purple Pics" and "Newbie Grower needs". That's correct.
Opening the thread where you have the alerts marks them as "read" automatically, hence why it wouldn't be 7 or 5 where you'll have to click on each alert just so they no longer get highlighted.
I'm guessing the other 2 emails for this thread have been marked as read before somehow?
This should show you the full list of recent alerts:
Code:
https://www.420magazine.com/community/account/alerts